Thursday, November 10, 2011

Love's Labour's Lost

We already covered my 100th show of the year, the deeply disappointing and pretty ridiculous Thomas Bradshaw play Burning. Now it's time for the 100th post! Which means...well, it's another disappointment. Don't worry: I know the next three posts are going to be about stuff I liked!

I love that the Public Theater has a "Lab" program where they workshop shows. I love that I got to see Bloody Bloody Andrew Jackson there for $15 a few years back. And I love that they're tackling some of Shakespeare's less produced plays as part of the series because, ever the completist, I set the relatively stupid goal of seeing every Shakespeare play performed at least once. This program let me knock Timon of Athens off my list. Next month, it will take down Titus Andronicus (because the movie doesn't count). And this month, it allowed me to cross of Love's Labour's Lost.

I'm happy to report that the problems I had with the show have nothing to do with Shakespeare himself. Sure, the plot about four men taking a vow of chastity in order to further their academic pursuits only to be shortly thereafter visited by four beautiful women is as ridiculous by today's standard as most of his work, but that's just the nature of the beast. Someone had to establish the cliches.

The problems aren't even with the cast (well...mostly). Instead, I lay blame at the director's feet for turning out a show that felt somehow frantically dull. First of all, the script must have been hacked apart to turn this into a two hour show with no intermission. I don't know the show, but you can feel that pieces are missing. And say what you will about Shakespeare, the man was thorough. I never had the sense that his plays were incomplete, if you see where I'm going with this.

But let's move on to something more troubling: "Hangin' Tough." Yeah--the New Kids on the Block song. Which the four leading ladies ever so briefly do a little dance to. Well before they do the Beyonce "Single Ladies" dance. You want to give me a new interpretation of something that interpolates contemporary(-ish) pop culture? Fine. Do it. You want to jar me out of the moment forcefully? Go for it. But if you do? You better make a point. And I sure hope it's significant.

Little moments of ridiculousness are scattered through the show as though to highlight its outlandishness. Letters are monstrously large. Costumes are black and white except for the occasional burst of silly bold color. But here's the thing: the show is already silly. So why not just play it straight? The worst offender (and I'm not fully prepared to blame the actor in lieu of the director) is the performance of Samira Wiley as the page Moth who manages to add excess to excess and seems not a clown as much as a buffoon.

Other performers far significantly better. Stephanie diMaggio is delightful as the lusty wench Jacquenetta. And Francis Jue's curate might not have the biggest part, but he left the most significant impression.

In the final moments of the show, the cast joins together for a joyful musical number that jars us out of the ennui that set in almost imperceptibly over the two hour running time. But I have to say, I'd rather be let down by the last two minutes of a great show than lifted up by the finale of something so deeply mediocre. Ah well. Good reviews a'comin', I promise!

Wednesday, November 9, 2011

Justin Vivian Bond

I miss Kiki & Herb. For those who don't know, they were played by Justin Bond and Kenny Mehlman and were an old-timey lounge act with a hilarious back story and a penchant for covering increasingly bizarre songs. Who can say they've lived unless they've seen a trans woman in old-lady make-up do a balls out performance of "Wu-Tang Forever?" No one. That's who.

I first saw Kiki & Herb in the basement of the NYU Catholic Center (obviously) in '98 or '99. I also notably saw their farewell concert at Carnegie Hall (downtown goes uptown for real), their subsequent "second coming" at the same venue, and most notably for me, a concert at the Knitting Factory shortly after 9/11/01 that was searingly bleak, uncomfortably hysterical, and ultimately one of the most memorable things I've ever seen.

Point is, since the "second coming," they haven't been back on the scene together, but I've caught up with each many, many times--Kenny regularly at Our Hit Parade and Justin wherever she happens to play.

It was with great pleasure that I got a chance to check out her show the night before Halloween at Joe's Pub. The on stage chatter veered from estrogen therapy to Samhain Eve to lap dances and Casey Anthony. The tone, as ever, was caustic with an undercurrent of warmth and a hint of wonder, as bitter and bold as ever.

I really enjoyed the show which was loosely organized around the theme of "songs by dead people." So loosely, in fact, that many of the songs were by people who are alive and simply old. Which was confusing to be sure and did lead to a moment of genuine concern when she started singing Leonard Cohen's "Famous Blue Raincoat." Leonard is happily still among us.

Justin's voice perpetually sounds just this side of fully shot and always in danger of just tumbling over a cliff, but she can use that to find these incredible moments of pathos and humanity. But here's the thing: when she goes for funny, no one else can do what she does. When the target is earnest, I feel like there are wonderful moments but that they lack a level of transcendence that I know is possible. So maybe she doesn't want to be funny all the time. That's fine. And we still get shows that are pretty wonderful. But I walk away with that niggling voice suggesting I could have had an even better time. So...yeah. I miss Kiki & Herb. But in the meantime, I'm certainly not going to turn down an evening with Mx. Bond.

Thursday, November 3, 2011

Burning

I've had my eye on when I'd hit 100 posts because then I'd have seen my 100 shows, but now that I'm at post 98, I realize that I did skip writing about that one concert way back when and also did one post about two shows a few months ago. Which means that my 100th show of the year was The New Group's production of Burning at the Acorn Theater in Theater Row. The same space I saw my first show of the year in when I started the blog. OMG FULL CIRCLE.

So yeah, that might seem like kismet except...Burning. Umm...what to say?

Let's start here: at intermission, I had the following conversation:
Friend: "We're leaving...right?"
Me: "I know it's fucking weird, but I maintain that this COULD end up being brilliant."
Friend: "..."
Me: "No, I mean, it's experimental and interesting and going fascinating places, and we should keep an open mind and hey, I haven't been bored at all, so...yeah, it's super weird, but can you honestly say you have any idea what's going to happen next? Doesn't the fact that anything can happen make you at least curious enough to stay?"
Friend: "I bet the neo-Nazi fucks his sister."

Spoiler alert: act 2 opens with the neo-Nazi fingering his sister. FINE, friend. You were right. Whatever. I still wasn't bored.

Let's just try to do a reallllllly quick plot overview, mm-kay? Brace yourselves. So this 14-year-old wants to go to acting school but his mother dies of an overdose. He heads across the country to interview anyway and convinces an older gay couple to take him in, let him into the school, and have sex with him. Meanwhile, German neo-Nazi's sister is paralyzed as a result of a car accident that also killed their parents. Back in America, a black artist is preparing for an exhibition in Germany when his cousin dies of an overdose. Cousin's son wants him to pay for the funeral but blah blah class issues blah.

So we cover neo-Nazi's, race relations, pedophilia, AIDS, drugs, incest, and a whole bunch of other stuff over three hours as the storylines eventually work their ways together. It's about 14 times too absurd to take seriously as a drama, 5 times too facile to really work as a satire, and half as funny as it needs to be in order to be a comedy. So instead it's just a mess. A big, flailing, did-no-one-EVER-suggest-any-cuts mess.

Out of the 15 person cast, I'd guess maybe three of them kept their clothes on, so if you see the show you can take bets on who'll disrobe next. The nudity, like everything in the show, feels extraneous at best, seemingly there to shock or titillate but falling flat. The worst part is that pieces of the show feel like they could have had an impact. And other parts might legitimately challenge the viewer. But it's all so muddled that the only logical response is to sit back and think, "Really?" It's like every cultural fear of 1996 got together and decided to have an orgy.

Which is not to say I didn't find any moments affecting and other parts very funny. The line "I was in a vagina for a moment" was a stand-out in a too-offensive to actually be offensive monologue about a hermaphrodite rapist (I'm still not making any of this up).

It's telling that in a show that I THINK is aiming to be unnerving and funny, the only time I actually laughed in discomfort was in a quieter scene as two actors whispered to each other when an old man a few rows behind me (oh yeah--I should mention I was in the front row) suddenly screamed, "LOUDER!"

Any time I see something new that I think is crazy dumb I worry that somewhere down the line, that play will become a classic that no one understood when it was first performed. That I'll be the idiot decrying Genet or walking out on Chekhov. But in the case of Burning, I'm pretty secure saying no, it was actually just fucking stupid.

Wednesday, November 2, 2011

Willie Nelson

It's not a secret that I have a list of performers I want to see before they die. High on that list was one Mr. Willie Nelson. Now, Willie's only 78, but some people just look like they've really LIVED, you know? In any case, I wasn't going to take my chances and let his most recent concert slip me by, so I headed out to Jersey to catch his show.

There's something charming to me about a performer who is fully willing to be exactly who their audience wants them to be, to the extent that they almost parody themselves. And watching Willie line up a bunch of bandannas and then tie them on for a bit before throwing each into the audience...that was adorable. If only because he seemed to do it all in good humor. He was nothing if not a pro. Songs charged into each other, banter was kept to a minimum, and on we plowed through decades worth of material. It could have felt cold and calculated (and who knows, maybe it was), but with his voice sounding completely unchanged by the years and his guitar playing energetic and enthusiastic, it was a near perfect concert for someone who had never seen him before. From "On the Road Again" to his version of "Me and Bobby McGee," he played everything I could have hoped for. I would argue that he was never the most forward-thinking or innovative musician, but he writes a damn good tune nonetheless. And his new songs , a few of which he played amidst the two hour set showed the great humor and heart that he's always brought to the table.

The audience at the show was a pretty fascinating cross-section of people that went from business suits to neck tattoos. And the curiosity factor about who would get thrown out for drunken misbehavior next definitely added a level of tension to the show. For the record, the first two people ejected didn't even make it to the end of the first song. And there was a 47-year-old woman who wasn't about to go without a fight (which oddly involved her hollering her age repeatedly).

What else is there to say? Willie Nelson is the flannel pajamas of music--cozy and warm and possibly going to lull you into a slumber--in a good way. And if he does an 80th birthday tour, I'll get out there to see him again for sure.

Monday, October 31, 2011

Chinglish

I don't totally understand how Chinglish ended up on Broadway which I don't mean in a bad way. It's just a little small and specific for a large house, and while it certainly has a lot to recommend it, I didn't find it outstanding enough to fully understand who thought it needed to come to New York in a production this big.

Gary Wilmes plays Daniel, a white American who heads to China to land a job making signs for a new stadium in Guanxing. He lands a British translator who agrees to act as his consultant to land the contract and offers to exploit his contacts with the minister Cai Guoliang to make that happen. There are two major complicating factors. The first is the minister's top aide Xi Yan who seems alternately desirous of sabotaging any possible deal and of making sure it goes through. The second, more thematically important, is that communication across language and cultural barriers proves challenging.

Mistranslation is the theme of the evening and the basis for much of its truly amusing comedy. Angela Lin as an overwhelmed/under-accurate translator in the first scene was the highlight of the show for me. Since much of the show is in Mandarin, the actors seem to have been directed to really oversell everything. Lin best masters acting at full volume while also seeming immediately knowable. As the show goes on, the issue of translation becomes less about words than about concepts--the challenge of crossing cultural barriers not only professionally but personally. Daniel and Xi Yan begin an affair, and through it, we explore the differences between the two as individuals but also as cultural emissaries. The language gags of the early parts of the show give way to meatier emotional issues that lend the show weight. And while the resolution is genuinely moving, I found the play to be a touch unbalanced, never really settling on a tone that felt fully committed.

Still, it's strong material with moments alternately hysterical and deeply affecting. If anything, it felt like a great, great show that should have been one act and run under two hours which could have been done with relatively minimal editing. It's one of those plays that really drives home how artificial the two act structure can feel.

It's nice to see a show hit Broadway that isn't cast with stars. It would have been nicer if I was more fond of the lead actor who felt a bit limited in terms of range, playing the entire show mildly baffled and affable. He's charming, but he never seems to develop very much so his performance just felt really static. I found myself wishing they HAD star cast because I would have loved to see what Jason Segel from Forgetting Sarah Marshall would have been like in the role. If only the producers had called me... Jennifer Lim as Xi Yan fares better. Excellently, in fact. She projects a sincere confidence throughout even when frustrated, angry, or wounded. She plays Xi as a relatively non-expressive woman (at least compared to the mugging going on around her), but she conveys more about her character than anyone else and ends up the emotional and intellectual heart of the show. Which is maybe a touch unfortunate for Wilmes who is so completely outshone.

So in the end...very good. And thoughtful. It just seems not 100% finished, and that's a shame because I think it could have been legitimately great.

Wednesday, October 26, 2011

Taylor Mac

I don't actually remember the first time I saw Taylor Mac, and this seems like a hideous lapse in my memory since I'm now pretty sure he's a genius. I do know that I found him totally intimidating with his crazy make-up and pseudo-drag. His look read a bit confrontational to me. And maybe it is, but now when I look at him, I see a stellar performer with a ton of heart and a surreal sense of humor who also gives really good face.

Taylor's epic five hour masterpiece The Lily's Revenge was one of the greatest nights I've spent at the theater (or really anywhere). It actually felt magical. Like for real magical, not I'm-hyperbolizing-magical. His show The Walk across America for Mother Earth earlier this year didn't fully hold up in comparison, but how could it? It was still wonderful.

And last Sunday at the new and improved Joe's Pub, he told the audience of a new show he's working on that I would actually think about killing someone to get a ticket to. A history of pop music in 24 consecutive hours of concert, it's not only about covering the ground. It's about endurance, what happens to the voice under duress, and I assume, the impact of sustained viewership on an audience. Because what his work always has, even at its most outrageous and outlandish, is a depth of humanity that it seems can only be authentically captured by moving into the realm of the abstract.

At the first of a series of evenings trying out songs for the 24 hour show, he tackled on decade only-the 1970s. From "Bohemian Rhapsody" to "Put the Lime in the Coconut" to a Broadway song so obscure that even I had never heard of it, he dove into disparate seeming material and managed to make it all feel of a piece. He may not have worked out a narrative yet, but the bits of patter between songs did loosely connect to his goals with the concert, his family history, and his own connection to music.

Though he has the capacity to shock and the greater capacity to make just about anything amusing, it's his ability to cut through every layer of artifice (his own and that of the material) to moments of breathtaking sincerity that draw me to him. He just fascinates me, and I'd watch him do anything. Even for 24 hours.

Tuesday, October 25, 2011

The Phantom of the Opera

Phantom of the Opera has the very special distinction of being the first Broadway show I ever disliked. Drunk on the wonder of live theater, I stepped into the Majestic Theater 15 years ago prepared to be dazzled. I found myself curiously underwhelmed and rather confused. Not just confused as to why the show was an enormous hit (it was already 10 years in though still well off becoming the longest running musical of all time) but confused as to what the hell was actually happening.

Revisiting the show for the first time ever, I still don't know why it's the biggest hit ever, but I at least know why I was so confused about the plot: it's insanely stupid. Not the idea of a murderous phantom living beneath an opera house and training a young ingenue to be a star. That's silly, but it's also just good gothic campy fun. What's stupid is how many storylines the show crams in without ever really bothering to allow any of them to accrue any gravitas or get very deep. Or even very spooky. Hey, isn't it kind of upsetting that the phantom just killed that...oh shit, look at all the candles!

One might wonder why I bothered going back to a show I knew I didn't like. First of all, the tickets were free. But more importantly, I thought that my taste for camp might be more developed than it was at 16. And I also thought it would be great fun to watch a show staged at a time when hundreds of costumes and hugely involved sets were still financially feasible. "Masquerade," the opening of the second act, is almost gasp-inducing in its sheer scale. An enormous staircase filled with dozens of actors in hugely involved costumes for a masked ball, it's pure eye candy. It also happens to be (in my opinion), the best song in the show. And there's a certain charm to the fact that during an early opera scene they pull on a life-sized replica of an elephant. An elephant! These days, we'd get a projection on a scrim and two folding chairs.

But as it turns out, lavish doesn't equal entertaining, at least in my book (see my previous review of Zarkana). And while there's so much potential here, I'd rather just read the book. As many people as there are on stage, the show feels deeply impersonal. No one has to do all that much acting (least of all the Phantom) because every role is painted in the very broadest strokes.

The musical staging (I hesitate to call it choreography) is stilted at best; the songs mostly all sound the same; and there's essentially no ending. Which makes sense for a show that mostly also has no backstory.

So why do I think it's been running forever? A few reasons: some people do just love seeing their dollars at work on the stage; the show at this point is its own brand which is probably self-sustaining; you can plop probably ANY halfway decent actor into any role and not gain or lose much; the show requires very little of its audience except the most facile emotionality; and who doesn't love to hear some big belty notes...even when they're prerecorded. AHEM.

I don't want to sound super snobby or contrary. I feel compelled to point out that I loooooove Les Miz. And while I think some of the lyrics of Miss Saigon are crazy stupid, it's lovely, admittedly silly, and still wonderful. I'm actually really fine with big dumb shows. As long as they're big dumb and FUN. Or moving. Or entertaining. Which is why I think Wicked should close tomorrow but Sister Act could run for years.

So...yeah. I hate Phantom of the Opera. I hate that it's the longest running show on Broadway, and I hate that it's probably got another 10-15 years in it. But if it ever DOES close, I'd love to play dress-up in all those costumes.