Wednesday, May 4, 2011

The Normal Heart


Every so often, I go into "theme" mode with what I'm reading and every book I pick up is about the same subject. Usually, the more depressing the topic, the more likely I'll get caught up. I once spent four months only reading novels set during West African civil wars. Another time, I dedicated myself to reading AIDS literature of the mid-80s: Paul Monette's memoirs, And the Band Played On, Queer and Loathing, the essays of Andrew Holleran...really upbeat stuff. But I had never read Larry Kramer's The Normal Heart. I had read (and loved) his scabrous novel Faggots, and knew stories of the play's original run at the Public, when the original leading man died of the disease a few months into the run, the walls of the theater were updated with the names of those who passed away, and the production went on to break records and became the theater's longest running show ever. I just hadn't actually read it, and for some reason, I anticipated that it would end up being a bit of a museum piece--political theater of a particular time that didn't hold up except as a document of a moment.



Last year, I was lucky enough to catch the reading that the current Broadway production of the show is based on. I won't lie. Part of what drew me in was the cast: Glenn Close, Jack McBrayer, and Patrick Wilson among them. But the two best things that came out of the night for me were how wonderful actor turned director Joe Mantello was in the central role of Ned Weeks, and how fantastic the play actually is. It was scarily prescient given when it was written, but it also holds up as a deeply moving snapshot of a community in crisis. It's shot through with humor, but its vitality comes from the enormity of rage at its core.



The play is, lets be real, completely autobiographical. Ned Weeks is Larry Kramer, founder of the Gay Men's Health Crisis, notorious loudmouth and asshole. And in a lot of ways, the play is his way of showing that he was right all along while simultaneously serving as a mea culpa for his less than stellar behavior. What makes it hold up is Kramer's ability to paint all of the characters around him with compassion and understanding, getting just enough distance to give every character around his space to breathe and enough saving grace not to wallow in their bad judgments.



From reading to full production, all but two cast members changed. It's not a slight to those in the reading that they are (with one exception) outshone by the current cast. After all, in the first go-around there was about a week to prepare and everyone was on script. Now in a fully realized, though still spare, production the action feels more immediate, more real, and even more moving. Jim Parsons is phenomenal as Teddy Boatwright, Southern gentleman, flirt, cad, and compassionate caregiver. He gets most of the show's lighter moments but never loses sight of the stakes around him. It was crushing to read a letter Kramer distributed after the show and learn that the real Tommy had killed himself. Joe Mantello is perfection as Ned Weeks. Along with Mark Rylance and Al Pacino, he is one of three actors this season who gave performances that are among the best I've ever seen. In Mantello's hands, Ned is a dragon, but a compassionate one--full of rage borne only out of love, unable to contain himself because of the wrongs he sees done even as his actions ruin his own life. This man who could be seen as a pretentious blowhard is portrayed with deep humanity that allows us to see him (and by proxy his creator, Kramer) for the truly heroic souls they are. As his lover, John Benjamin Hickey is so charming and so thoughtful and so romantic that his eventual illness (this is not really a spoiler--it's an AIDS play) is all the more heartbreaking.



Only Lee Pace seems out of place. As Bruce, the more charismatic, attractive, sensible co-founder of the GMHC, he seems stranded amidst greater talents and can't quite rise to the occasion. His monologue in the second act was delivered astoundingly by Patrick Wilson in the reading. Pace's speech felt hollow, tried on, and just...less real. What should be the first significant gut-punch of the night doesn't hurt as much as it should, and that's a shame.



That aside, this is a thrilling night out, if you can count as thrilling something that ends with an entire auditorium audibly sniffling and red eyes all around. That letter from Kramer which is handed out on your way out of the theater is a depressing testament to just how current the show really still is, but also to the fact that the old blowhard just won't give up. Bless him. If you see the show and get the letter, I recommend you wait until you're alone to read it. I was a wreck after reading it. The man has a way with words, and his play, perhaps his greatest achievement, is living proof.

Monday, May 2, 2011

born bad


born bad has no business being as good as it is. It’s a 55 minute play with highly stylized language and action in which no one really says much of anything. Six members of a family stand around a bunch of starkly lit chairs saying cryptic things for just under an hour. Five minutes in, clueless as to where anything was going, I was prepared to write it off as some wannabe Beckett nonsense with nothing to say but a whole lot of pretentious ways to say it.

And then, curiously, the pieces started to come together. The characters, I realized, weren’t talking about vague somethings; they were talking about one very specific something. Their vagueness, and how the author treated it, all related to this family’s inability to confront their secrets, whether the nearly silent father who remains uninvolved, the coolly distant mother who wants not to believe what is being said, or even the barreling force of nature Dawta, demanding to be heard, but still afraid to give voice to the specifics of what she is talking about.

As it turns out, born bad tells a story that has been told many times before. But in its presentation and its refusal to spell things out in any literal way, it finds a creeping, disturbing, beautiful, and heartbreaking way of not only dealing with the events of this one family’s past, but confronting the myriad ways in which they’ve failed to communicate with each other about them.

Thank the gods the play isn’t any longer than it is because by the end, I was deeply, wonderfully upset and moved. It’s a gutpunch of a play, but in the best, most transformative way.

The cast is Re. Dic. You. Luss. Heather Alicia Simms is the picture of righteous rage as Dawta. Quincy Tyler Bernstine who was amazing in Ruined is no less so here, balancing the most humorous character of the piece ever so carefully on the edge of this deeply tragic show. LeRoy James McLain is smashingly sweet and sincere; Crystal Dickinson is a revelation as the sister you desperately want to slap, and Elain Graham and Michael Rogers in the rather small roles of the parents, are nauseating villains all too easy to believe in.

It’s an incredible show that, like Black Watch the week before, left me shaken.

Thursday, April 28, 2011

The House of Blue Leaves


I’ve only been doing this for a few months, but I still find it interesting (and telling) that for the first time yet, I completely barreled past a show I had seen and totally forgot to write about it. It was like it hadn’t even happened. So, sure, there are lots of forgettable shows, but how many disappear within days? And of those, how many involve nuns climbing through windows, a deaf actress exploding, and a soldier disguising himself as an altar boy to attempt to kill the pope?

The House of Blue Leaves shouldn’t slip from the mind as easily as the current production does. It’s a wild farce imbued with incredible sadness, and though it’s 40 years old, it’s as timely as ever in its consideration of how people long for fame as a way to legitimize themselves when really, they might not actually be that talented or special.

But as played by Ben Stiller and Jennifer Jason Leigh, two-thirds of the main characters in the show go out with more of a whimper than a shout. Edie Falco is predictably fantastic as sullen crazy lady Bananas, but as her husband Artie, Stiller is kind of just a sad sack who lacks the kinetic energy that would make you believe he was really that determined to make it as a songwriter. And Jennifer Jason Leigh is just no good at comedy. I happen to think she’s a pretty bad actress who occasionally trundles into the perfect part. The movie Georgia, for example. Or Single White Female. As Sally Bowles in Cabaret back in ’99, she gave one of the worst musical performances I have ever seen. And as Bunny Flingus in this show, she’s shrill and shouty without ever seeming as funny OR as pathetic as she should. How do you make a woman named Bunny Flingus NOT funny??

When I started this blog, I expected that I’d derive more joy from writing about the bad shows than about the good. It certainly seems easier to enumerate the ways in which something fails than try to distinguish what makes a wonderful show gel. But writing about this one right now, I just feel kind of bummed about it. It’s a great play. It’s just such a flat production. Things come temporarily to life when three nuns climb off the roof into Artie’s apartment to watch the Pope on TV; the exploding actress is a pretty great gag; and Christopher Abbott is weirdly charming as Bananas and Artie’s son Ronnie (“weirdly charming” might just mean adorable), but all in all, it’s a flat evening punctuated by flashes of brilliance from the indomitable Edie Falco who should probably star in everything ever.

Wednesday, April 27, 2011

Peter and the Starcatcher


Reviewers were practically pooping themselves to talk about how genius the Peter Pan prequel Peter and the Starcatcher was. I continued to resist the show for literally as long as possible. When I finally broke down and decided to go, I went online and got the single last ticket that wasn’t sold out. So what cause the ruckus and excitement? Well…I’m not totally sure.

This is a totally cute show that offers up a fun possible backstory for Peter Pan. It’s Wicked-lite. By which I mean less original than Wicked but also less shrieky and annoying. It’s also staged for about .1% of what that megamusical probably cost—it’s all ropes and ladders and “theater magic” instead of big set pieces and lame effects. I expected that part of things to be thoroughly charming, but it was all just less fresh and exciting than I expected.

None of this is the cast’s fault. As the boy who would be Peter Pan, Adam Chanler-Berat is adorable and innocent. As the girl who led him to become Peter, saving his life and bringing him to Neverland, Celia Keenan-Bolger is wonderfully sweet with just the right amount of preteen sass. And as the pirate who becomes Captain Hook, Christian Borle was delightfully slapstick and over-the-top. So what went wrong?

Here’s one thing: I would be happy to never again see a show with wildly anachronistic jokes awkwardly and cheaply shoved in. It’s really a children’s show (even if it’s likely a children’s show for adults). We did not need a Tea Party joke. Too easy, folks. Too easy. And too out of place in terms of time period, in terms of tone, and in terms of taste. Which is the sort of thing that continues to pop up throughout the show, preventing me from ever feeling like I truly engaged. A joke that I was much more entertained by was the line, “He’s more elusive than the melody in a Phillip Glass opera.” But that’s a great line…for a different show.

The writers had source material to work from, and there’s a great story there. It’s just disguised by a lot of cheap jokes and lame sight-gags. Did we need the whole cast in drag as mermaids at the beginning of the second act? Not really.

I’m all for low-humor, bad drag, and all-out silliness, but it never gelled with the story that was actually being presented, so I felt curiously short-changed by a show that had a lot of potential. I couldn’t love this just because I wanted to, but I really DID want to. Ah well! I’ve been on a great streak, so one disappointment is hardly the end of the world. It’s just a pain when it’s so hugely hyped.

Tuesday, April 26, 2011

Jerusalem


I lucked into some free seats at the opening night of Jerusalem through a friend of a friend. At the second intermission (it’s a long show), someone came along with bags of flowers for us to toss at the stage during curtain call. The person I was with turned to me and asked, “Why the hell would you live anywhere else?” I have to say: it warmed the cockles. As did Jerusalem, the totally divisive play just imported from London about a retired daredevil named Rooster whose trailer in the woods is a landing ground for all sorts of local misfits, drug users, and aimless teens.

At first intermission, some crotchety old dude behind me croaked, “Is it ABOUT anything other than being druuuunk?!” Browsing through some message boards and other blog reviews, this is something that came up fairly often. People somehow read the show as three hours of watching drunk people mess about. I will just say this: people are stupid.

Jerusalem is about one man clutching onto his ratted, dirty corner of the world in the face of oncoming land development. It’s also about the adolescent anarchy that he so fully embodies, its vibrancy and necessity, but also the way we turn away from things we embraced in younger years. It’s a celebration of childlike qualities that get squashed not only by bad real estate development, but by the soul-deadening nature of some more mature, responsible decisions people make in life. However, it’s not as simple as a love poem to anarchy because as embodied by Mark Rylance, Rooster is no one’s idea of a hero. He’s slovenly, emotionally and physically crippled, and yet still commands a vaguely mythic air about him, one that is echoed in the plays references to giants and Stonehenge and fairies and saints.

I was worried about understanding the play when I first went in because I had heard much made about it being a “state of the nation” play about England, but I also think that’s a pretty narrow read. While there are definitely things about it that are very specifically British (the whole thing happens on St. George’s Day, which I had never even heard of before), it’s a more universal story than that. The Times review seemed curiously accurate in pointing out that it’s the sort of play that could have been written anytime after 1920. The drugs change and the clothes change, but when you get right down to it, this is a railing against the sprawling mess of modernity.

Bottom line: it’s a play that I liked very, very much, but what lifts it above just being a damn good play is the fact that Mark Rylance is probably the most charismatic, enigmatic, and generally damned talented actors I’ve ever seen. A lot of review have been calling his performance things like “one for the ages,” or “the best in years,” and blah, blah, blah. The crazy thing is that even though I had heard all that going in, I still was shocked by how fucking great he was, how repulsive and loveable and funny and scary he managed to be all at once. It’s a huge performance—extremely physical, highly emotive, and all that jazz, but it never feels actorly. It just…is. I was completely mesmerized by him in La Bete, but I think he actually improved upon himself. I’m ever more disappointed that I didn’t go see him in Boeing-Boeing. But given the great stuff I HAVE seen, I try not to dwell too, too much on what I missed.

Wednesday, April 20, 2011

Black Watch

Here's the thing about Black Watch, currently playing at St. Ann's Warehouse in Dumbo: it has played New York twice before. The first time I couldn't afford as many shows as I do now and didn't prioritize it. The second time, I didn't realize how short the run was, and I got sold out. When they announced a third and (presumably final) engagement, I snatched those tickets super fast. Before the show started, I read a piece in the program about a journalist (I think) who went to the opening of the show in LA with three American servicemen who didn't particularly know what to expect, only that it was a play about a branch of the Scottish military in Iraq. They expected an anti-war message and were heartened by the show which turned out to be more a history of a single military organization and the story of comradery in the troop when deployed in Iraq in 2004-ish.

I felt ready to take in the show. I consider myself a virulent pacifist, but I do have enough appreciation for the particular fascinations of the specific psyche of the soldier. I found The Hurt Locker mesmerizing. I think All Quiet on the Western Front is fascinating. While I can't understand what would make someone join the armed forces, I can be engaged by their stories. As the show got under way, mixing video, reenacted interviews between the show's creators and the troops, and choreographed movement (that I would not define as dance), I started to feel more and more uncomfortable. The soldiers were often brash, violent off the battlefield, and distressingly homophobic and sexist. I started to dislike them more and more and was (if I'm being honest) angry with the show for glamorizing and legitimizing them. This, it turns out, was reactionary on my part. I'll explain:

What really was bothering me wasn't the depiction of the behavior. It WAS the behavior. It all rang a little too true. I was annoyed with the play, it seems, for being so honest. This was not a realization I had all of a sudden but slowly gained over time. Because what's dazzling about the show (and it's really the whole show, not just the play itself) was that while it portrayed these characters more and more specifically, it was also leading us to a place where the stakes became high enough that the soldiers were acting on instinct, emotion, and trust. So we got to know them more and more, and maybe we disliked some of them or were angry with them, but then the war became more dangerous and we watched them cohere into a unit under pressure whose unity made them easier to respect and admire and, dare I suggest, understand.

My annoyance registered clearly about 30 minutes in, and there was some time there that I was outside of the action, regarding it at a distance. Giving myself back over to the performance happened more gradually. I didn't notice it until the end. And the end... The wordless last few minutes of the show were among the most astonishing that I've ever seen. The squad groups up. Bagpipes play. The soldiers march. Back and forth on parade grounds, changing directions, coming apart and regrouping as the music became louder and louder. I can't explain what was so amazing about it. And I don't have the ability to accurately capture of what was happening physically or emotionally on stage. But as it built and built, I noticed that I was actually trembling in the face of a theatrical moment so perfect that it cut through preconceived notions while dazzling the senses and holding the audience as its own singular entity, unifying them in the act of witnessing. I wept for these characters I had so disliked, and as corny as it sounds, it's those sort of moments of transcendent humanity that keep me going to plays. When something cuts through the bullshit so effectively and challenges me so particularly, all I can do is be thankful for the opportunity to have seen it.

And hey! After getting off track when I went out of town, I'm all caught up on shows I've seen! Happily for my six or seven dedicated readers, I have tickets for something new tomorrow!

Tuesday, April 19, 2011

The Intelligent Homosexual's Guide to Capitalism and Socialism with a Key to the Scriptures


Spending three and a half hours watching a new Tony Kushner play was enervating, provocative, and left me feeling like a little bit of an idiot. There's something about watching the work of someone who is clearly brilliant that inspires me to learn and know more but also makes me feel a little bad about some of my...less thoughtful entertainment options. You don't want to leave The Intelligent Homosexual's Guide to Capitalism and Socialism with a Key to the Scriptures and want to pop in the headphones for the new Britney album is all I'm saying. You DO want to go home and do some reading on the labor history of the United States. Which I did! And THEN I listened to some Britney...I couldn't help myself!

Regardless, let me try to quickly explain several hours of dense, character heavy show. Gus is an elderly father of three who has long had close ties with the Communist party in America. Now 72, he is preparing to kill himself, but before he does so wants the approval of his three children (because he's a twisted fuck--more later)--Pill, a middle aged gay man who can't stop cheating on his partner with a hustler; Empty, a lesbian whose partner is expecting their first child perhaps against Empty's real wishes; and V, the least academic of the three children, the one straight one, and the only child who keeps particularly close to Gus these days. Setting things in motion, more or less, is Clio, Gus's ex-nun sister who requests a unanimous vote to either give Gus the blessing to kill himself or to force him not to.

To get all literary on you for a second, if Angels in America is Kushner's The Corrections, iHo is his Freedom--still expansive and brilliant but less forgiving of its characters incredibly deep flaws. I always wondered why one particular character in Angels seemed to bear the brunt of Kushner's ire, earning the least happy ending in that particular play when I felt he deserved better. In iHo (note: I didn't come up with the nickname), no one gets an especially happy ending, and frankly, none of them really earns it. These are selfish people. Complicated, yes. Believable as well. Ultimately, though, they grow less and less likeable throughout the show, inciting pity more than caring. That's not a complaint. When after three hours I realized that I deeply hated a character I had loved at the beginning but still felt bad for him, I was mostly impressed by Kushner's willingness to take the audience to such dark places, but also still held deeply in the thrall of the play's incredible thoughtfulness. Because while I might not like these people, I was still invested in them. It's a hugely tricky balance--free of sentimentality and easy choices. It doesn't make it an easy show to watch, but it does make it fascinating.

But dwelling on suicide and the more distressing aspects of the play makes this sound more somber than it is. And the narrative is shot through with quite a bit of humor. Secondary characters like Empty's partner Maeve (perfectly played by Danielle Skraastad) and V's wife Sooze are wonderfully funny. Aunt Clio as well has hysterical moments though hers are balanced with others of sheer pathos by the incomparable Kathleen Chalfant who delivers a performance that is hugely quiet yet leaves a resounding impression. Not a single movement is wasted. Not a moment is missed. She's wonderful. Not everyone is loathsome. I quite enjoyed Yale-educated hustler Eli who Michael Esper plays as terribly sweet and almost heroically lost. And in a single scene, Molly Price plays Shelle (the less revealed about her, the better) and brings a crushing humanity and bareness of emotion that nearly splits the play wide open.

Most thrilling for me was seeing Stephen Spinella who created the role of Prior in Angels in America create a new Kushner role. As oldest son Pill, he's a devastating mess. His father notes that he is the child most likely (and willing and fated) to "break things." I didn't like him, and I didn't understand why his partner would stay with him, but pieces of him, I felt I understood, deeply and uncomfortably. That contrast between what I felt and what I knew--how I reacted to characters vs. how I understood them--that's what was ultimately so wonderful and eye-opening about the show. It lacks the humanity and sheer overwhelming power of Angels in America, but when you've created one of the most substantial masterpieces of contemporary theater, I think it's fair to say you're still prett great when you don't quite equal your earlier work. This is at once darker, more restrained, and less accessible than Angels, so it's less enjoyable, but damned if it isn't still pretty amazing.