Sunday, April 17, 2011

Good People


It's often uncomfortable to watch a show about the contemporary poor on Broadway. There you are, having spent a significant amount of money to watch a play, indicating your own expendable income. And on stage are people just scraping by, presentationally at least. You might be asked to feel bad for them, worse you might be asked to pity them, or worst you might be asked to deify them for their spirit. Any of the options tends to leave you (me) feeling like an asshole who spent a family's food budget for the week for the opportunity to sit in a dark theater and watch people perform for you.

Happily, Good People is a show about people scraping by that very nearly dares you to pass judgment based on the main character Margie (hard G) played by Frances McDormand. You might want to judge her for being so aggressive, but the next scene will significantly soften your attitude toward her. And then another scene comes along and makes you think she might be a bitch after all. Eventually you settle in and accept that you're not being asked to look at Margie as a stand-in for all the downtrodden people of South Boston. She's an individual character brought fully and remarkably to life by Frances McDormand.What becomes satisfying is that while Good People deals in issues of money and class, it is not a play about being poor. It's a play about one woman's very complicated life and is driven by her need to find gainful employment. She's not going to be arrested for stealing a loaf of bread, and you know she won't tumble head over feet into a life on the streets selling her hair for money, but the stakes are still high enough that her urgency is well-placed and sets the plot in beautiful motion.

Margie's friend and landlord (the exceptional and hysterical Becky Ann Baker and Estelle Parsons) lead her to consider approaching her high school ex-boyfriend (a wonderful Tate Donovan) to see about getting a job. He has escaped Southie and become a doctor, and Margie thinks he might owe her just enough favor to let her answer phones or point her towards someone who might have work open.

What follows is a play that gently expands to encompass larger and larger issues and develop more and more momentum. It's a well-formed, old fashioned play in the best of sense. All the pieces will fit. All the scenes play out at a realistic, almost leisurely pace, and every time you think you know what the play is "about," something comes along to gently confound your expectations.

It also helps that the play is very, very funny. For a show that opens with the main character losing her job and is centrally concerned with her inability to provide for her developmentally disabled daughter, there are a lot of jokes, and they all land. Credit to the ridiculously well-balanced ensemble that resists the urge to showboat even though each has ample opportunity to do so.

At play's end, I didn't feel I had seen anything revolutionary or utterly new, but I was left with the incredibly satisfying feeling of seeing a perfectly constructed play beautifully performed. As the seasons winds down, it is to me the best new play that's arrived. I still need to see Jerusalem (next week), but given the outpouring of love for the remedial War Horse, I'm sure that's going to win the Tony. Well...it was better than High.

Tuesday, April 12, 2011

The People in the Picture


The Holocaust and comedy were integrated pretty well in Life Is Beautiful. The Holocaust and comedy AND musical theater? Shit got even trickier. But you know what? I totally dug The People in the Picture.

Musical theater's most versatile diva, Donna Murphy, is rocking every inch of said ability to move between comedy and drama, playing ugly and beautiful, young and old, vibrant and afflicted with Alzheimers. Because the people who wrote this show had the balls to have a single person play a character at the ages of roughly 30 and 80. Murphy is Raisel, an elderly grandmother in New York trying to pass along the history of the Yiddish theater troupe she was the star of to her granddaughter Jenny played by the wonderful 10 year old Rachel Resheff. Raisel's daughter, Red (played by Nicole Parker) complicates matters by being intentionally distant from her heritage.

As Raisel spins her stories of her troupe, the titular folks from the past come to vibrant life. So back and forth we go between 1977 and the late 30s/early '40s. From comedy to drama. And from Yiddish vaudeville to contemporary Broadway ballads. It probably shouldn't work. And for many, it probably won't. But what I enjoyed about this was that it presented a story rooted in the Holocaust without being "a Holocaust story." Without denying the tragedy of what happened, it manages to celebrate the persistence of storytelling and the resilience of the human spirit.

To do so, it traffics in some cliches, and some of the old-time troupe gets short shrift really just standing in as representatives of the tragedy to come. Chip Zien is wonderful in a small part even though you just sort of wait for him to get killed. Joyce Van Patten gets explosive laughs on a few lines, which might actually be her only lines. Then there's Andie Mechanic who looks to be about seven or eight and has a shockingly adult, booming, clarion voice.

Some of the numbers are expendable, notably a number called "Hollywood Blondes" that doesn't move the story forward OR provide much insight into the particular moment it represents. That said, whether the vaudevillean "The Dybbuk" and "Ich, Uch, Feh" or the contempo "Bread and Theatre" or " We Were Here," the majority of numbers score.

I worry that this show will be easy for some to dismiss because it's a little messy and walks a number of tightropes. It would be a shame if people weren't led to it. It's probably the least buzzed about musical of the year, but it (to me) is better than most--whether Priscilla, Catch Me If You Can, or even Bloody Bloody Andrew Jackson (which I quite liked...before I started blogging).

Really, though, if nothing else, it's a glorious opportunity to see Donna Murphy work her magic. She gets to do character work as the grandmother slowly losing her mind, show of her laser precise comedic timing in the theater numbers, and put over super emotional material like the songs "Child of My Child" in ways so clean and so specific that the whole enterprise looks effortless in spite of whiplash changes from old to young character in front of our eyes.

There's a real warmth to this show and enough genuinely pleasing about it that I was happy to forgive any quibbles, ignore any schmaltz, and just embrace it. I hope others will as well.

Monday, April 11, 2011

High


The opportunity to watch Kathleen Turner play a recovering alcoholic nun/therapist with a foul mouth? Yes, please! That was basically my entire decision making process for going to see the new play High which has made it to Broadway by way of a baffling decision making process. The playwright's last show tanked. This show got pretty bad reviews out of town. There are roughly ten million other new shows opening in the next month, so there's no reason to believe that there's a wide open audience ready to buy tickets to this. Yes, there are those out there (me) who assume that if the play was good that would be lovely, but if it was bad that would be even lovelier. Kathleen Turner as a recovering alcoholic nun, people!

This show's gonna tank. I think that's a pretty safe assumption. Sister Kathleen Turner is asked by her priest superior to counsel a super-addict gay teen hooker. She totally doesn't want to, but she does. Things go badly. Addiction is hard! Therapy is also hard! Writing a play, it seems, is harder yet.

High is just too poorly conceived and clunky to ever get off the ground. At times, I tried to figure out whether there were bad acting choices being made or whether there was simply no way for some lines to be rendered realistic. I suspect the latter. Which is especially unfortunate given that the author's bio included a thank you to his sponsor for "saving his life." When a recovering addict makes addiction and recovery look totally fake, you know you're in less than skilled writerly hands. People should start out by writing what they know, yes. But some people just shouldn't write.

In the end, there's enough camp about the show to make it relatively entertaining. The show is at least relatively quick moving and coherent, so there's a likeability there in spite of the larger ineptitude. So yeah...I'm glad I went. But I wouldn't recommend that anyone else should.

Wednesday, April 6, 2011

LCD Soundsystem


I'm always so afraid of missing something amazing that if you tell me it's my last chance to see or do something, I'll be there. So it was with LCD Soundsystem's "LAST SHOW EVER" at Madison Square Garden. Was I a fan of the band? No. Did I love one of their songs? Yeah. Was the fact that tickets were affordable and the event felt "important" the only reason I went? You betcha.

Sadly for me, this was a concert for the superfans. I left after three hours of increasingly dull show. We hadn't even gotten to the encores yet. That one song I love? I didn't hear it. I had reached my fill of electronica, self-satisfaction, and being surrounded by the species Douchebaggus Fraternicus.

The show opened with the one-two punch of "Dance Yrself Clean" and "Drunk Girls," and I was super-excited for the ride. Yes, I found it silly that the band requested everyone show up to their last concert dressed in black and white. Yes, I was disconcerted by the number of glow sticks being thrown from the many levels of MSG. Yes, someone had already spilled beer on me. But it felt special. Exciting even. And "Daft Punk Is Playing at My House" can never not be good times. After about an hour of fun, we were told it was going to be a long show, so there would be some breaks mixed in. I do love a good intermission.

The band returned for the second set and played almost the entire song 45:33 which (and this REALLY bothers me) is actually 46 minutes long. The beginning of it was great. Comedian/musician Reggie Watts guested on it and was wonderful. No one around me had any idea who he was. Many asked. A bit later, Arcade Fire put in a guest appearance. Unpopular opinion alert: I hate Arcade Fire's music. But not as much as I hate the lead singer's hair. All they did was scream along "North American" whenever it came up in the song "North American Scum." It was...pointless.

If the second set hadn't happened, I probably would have enjoyed the third set. It's just...for me, repetitive dance music only works in limited doses. And while a lot of magazines have made the claim of late that LCD is basically the most important band ever, I'd argue that their sound is quite familiar and is really only elevated by clever lyrics. See: "New York I Live You, But You're Bringing Me Down." So when you're at Madison Square Garden with its hideously muddled sound and you can't really make out any of said lyrics or any of the between song banter. And when you add in the massive dose of self-congratulation that a "retirement concert" is all about...well, that's kind of deadly. So I ran for the hills. I didn't even make the balloon drop. But at least I can say I saw LCD Soundsystem's last show before their comeback. Because is any "last show" ever really a last show? And how does a one man band break up? I should have let a superfan have the seat. Ah well. Their loss. And...mine too. Hmm.

Monday, April 4, 2011

War Horse


Oh, kids. We have some catching up to do. A weekend of marathon madness left me woefully behind, so I'm a step ahead of you in knowing when the good reviews are coming. And there is one coming. But not yet!

Let me start this off that by saying on Thursday, I was basically dead on my feet and the last thing I wanted to do was go see a three hour play about horses. Was I prepared then to give War Horse the benefit of the doubt? Not especially. Do I think that really affected how I feel about it in the end? Also not especially. It's a tough question though because the people around me LOVED this show. We're talking rapturous response. Endless ovation upon the conclusion. Palpable excitement. And me Scrooge-ing it up in the middle of the crowd.

As a man behind me helpfully stated as we were walking out of the theater, "It's about the horse, but it's so much bigger than that. It's about the war." Yes, sir, thank you for your penetrative consideration of War Horse. Now that you've said that, I can see that it is about both horses and wars. And really folks, that's about all it's about.

Kid with cantankerous drunk father ends up with a horse. He loves the horse. And I mean, he LOVES this horse. Was there a subtext there? Probably not. Did pretending there was and following along with it give me more pleasure than the play itself? Absotutely. So the horse is raised, and lo, it is a wondrous horse. Then comically alcoholic father almost loses it in a bet, but son is able to save it. Phew! Then cliched sad sack father sells the horse to the war effort. Oh noes! Son, loving this horse sooooo much goes off to war to find his horse. Son is, I'm guessing, autistic, as he seems to love ONLY his horse and not be able to manage any actual human compassion. Then again, this is a really, really awesome horse.

Cut to hours of the horse and the son in the war. Will hey find each other? Will they be reunited? Do you even have to ask? In a melodrama as trite and predictable as this, conclusions are pretty much foregone. Son and horse will reunite and live magically ever after. It's like a Nicholas Sparks novel if Miley Cyrus was played by a horse. (Insert your own jokes here).

Listen, the puppets are undeniably amazing. Even though you can see through them to the people literally inside manipulating them, there is a vitality and lifelike quality that can't be denied. So when the horses gallop across the stage or stand and shiver or slowly approach someone they don't trust, there is something deeply believable about them. And you will have ample opportunity to stare at them and to believe.

All the humans die, more or less. Tons of horses die too. Tragic. A small child is trotted out to exploit audience emotions because war is sooooo much worse when kids are involved. Especially little French girls named Sophie who also love horses. And oh, just wait until everyone on stage is supposed to be speaking different languages, indicated by incredibly bad French, German, and British accents. I'm convinced the script actually looks like this: "Zees ees terr-ee-bluh." "Bollocks!" "Gesundheit!" And the random Irish-y folk songs that happen throughout? I. Can't. Even.

I resisted from the beginning, and I found it easier and easier to resist as the show went on. This is one of those silly "boy and his dog" stories you can find in some easy-reader children's book, but it's blown up to epic stature. There are some mighty thin bones holding this up. For me, the whole thing fell down about 20 minutes in. But what do I know? Everyone else was gasping at the pretty.

Friday, April 1, 2011

The Mountain Goats


I first encountered The Mountain Goats at a bit of a remove. At Kiki and Herb’s Carnegie Hall goodbye show, they performed “No Children,” a song that it is quite easy to fall instantly in love with. I tracked down the original and was surprised to learn that unlike how they performed it, it wasn’t a dialogue between two people, but sung by one man with a kind of nasal voice and flat affect. What was immediately funny as sung by a drag queen and accompanist made up to look like two elderly performers became a more haunting and angrier song when delivered as intended by John Darnielle who for all intents and purposes IS The Mountain Goats. I was intrigued.

Over the years, I’ve come to buy more and more of the seemingly infinite back-catalogue of MG albums. From the intensely personal The Sunset Tree to the bizarrely brilliant All Hail West Texas (recorded by Darnielle by himself on some really low-tech equipment) to the Biblically inspired The Life of the World to Come, the sounds have varied, but many things have remained constant: the output is prolific, the songwriting is sharply intelligent, and everything seems to be tinged with equal parts brilliance and madness. At least, that’s my take.

Though I’ve seen the band four or five times and have seven or eight of their albums, I cannot begin to compete with real Mountain Goats fans who seem to see every show and know every word to every song. It’s like they’re the favorite band of every autistic savant ever. It’s an impressive site to behold. And because among those fans, there are so many die-hard enthusiasts, the crowd at every show is reverent and wonderful.

All of that said, I didn’t have the BEST time at their show on Wednesday. It felt like a lot of it was focused on some of the group’s more moribund material, and while I do enjoy some sad-ass songs, there’s something anachronistic about standing around in a rock club listening to one man on a guitar sing quietly about someone dying. That is I-need-a-chair music. At least for me it is. But when he hit on songs with a rockier vibe or happier lyrics, the spirit soared. I can’t imagine it will ever not be thrilling to hear songs like “Love, Love, Love,” the aforementioned divorce anthem “No Children,” “The Best Ever Death Metal Band Out of Denton,” or the incredibly beautiful “This Year,” a song about friendship and survival. “There will be feasting and dancing in Jerusalem next year//I am gonna make it through this year if it kills me.”

Darnielle just has this wonderful openness that seems to invite anyone who has ever felt like an outsider (so…everyone) to revisit that moment while celebrating having moved on from it. It’s a strange sort of dwelling in the past as a celebration of the present, and everything seems rooted in such a deeply personal place for him that it’s absurdly easy to give yourself over to it.

I’ll close this by just quoting my favorite lyrics from “No Children.” The video’s above. It’s really worth checking out.

I hope I cut myself shaving tomorrow
I hope it bleeds all day long
Our friends say it's darkest before the sun rises
We're pretty sure they're all wrong
I hope it stays dark forever
I hope the worst isn't over
And I hope you blink before I do
Yeah I hope I never get sober

Tuesday, March 29, 2011

Angela Lansbury and Friends Salute Terrence McNally


The Acting Company puts on some solid benefits. Last year they did a staged reading of Larry Kramer's The Normal Heart which is now coming to Broadway next month. Let's just say Glenn Close was the weakest link in the cast. And I LOVE Glenn Close. They also did a tribute to John Kander with Debra Monk, Raul Esparza, Chita Rivera, and a dozen of theater's best singers performing his and Fred Ebb's songs. I got to see Chita sing "All that Jazz." Magic.

So naturally I snagged tickets for their latest benefit, Angela Lansbury and Friends Salute Terrence McNally. Well, maybe not so naturally. If I'm being totally honest, he's not a favorite of mine. Love, Valour, Compassion is a wonderful play that veers into cheap sentiment here and there. The Lisbon Traviata is hysterical, but it depends on a lot of in jokes that make it feel rather small. And his work on musicals is uneven. He wrote the book for Ragtime, one of my all-time favorites. But it's worth mentioning that I always felt the book was the weakest link. And his work on this season's Catch Me If You Can? I'll summarize in one word: ugh. But spending an evening watching excerpts of his work performed by a stellar group of individuals, I couldn't help but think that while I do have problems with his works on the whole, there are moments throughout that are beautiful, heartbursting moments of joy and compassion. If one thing is more clear from his work than anything else, it's that he seems to be a man who loves people. Flawed or troubled or bitchy or cruel, he still affords them moments of great sincerity and love.

Let's start with my arrival at the theater. I nearly knocked over Angela Lansbury. Thinking I was late to meet my friend, I started to charge into the crowd at the doors, then changed my mind, grabbed my phone, and made an about face...into a national treasure. If I had knocked over Angela Lansbury in front of a Broadway theater, I would have been lynched. I would have lynched myself! What can you say about the woman? She's 85 and she's stunning. She's 85 and still working. She's 85 and she still showed up at a benefit despite the fact that she was sick. The woman practically sparkles. And I almost took her out. Sigh.

Rather than give you the full recap of the night (there were a lot of people), I'll focus on the highlights. Bobby Steggert read a piece very near the beginning that very promptly brought a tear to my eye. I haven't been able to track it down yet (Google, you let me down!), but if I do, I'll post a link to it here. Summarized: life is lovely. And if we live in a world that could create a Shakespeare or Florence, Italy...isn't that a place worth living? The beauty of art, beautifully captured. Okay, there wasn't a tear in my eye. There were about 20 tears, and they were all over my face. I cry easily. It happens.

Alexandra Silber (who once thanked me in the comments here after I said nice things about her in Hello Again--which I'm seeing again on Friday!) performed an aria that I believe she will also perform in the play Master Class this summer. I do not know opera. I cannot comment on technicality or general skill. I CAN say that it was lovely. And that as ever, I adore hearing an unmic'ed voice. There was also a story about her finding herself licked in a closet at the audition for Master Class. I can see myself in this position ALL too easily. I'm also seeing the show in July and looking forward to seeing this performer I didn't know a month ago yet another time!

Speaking of people performing without microphones, John Glover went balls out and performed two pieces without the benefit of amplification. The first was from The Lisbon Traviata, and it was hysterical and wonderful. The second was from Love! Valour! Compassion!, and it was a great thrill to see him recreate part of his Tony winning performance--even if it's one of those sugary scenes of McNally's that I don't quiiiiiite love. On a side note, when I first read about that play, I thought it was Love! Velour! Compassion! As I was deep in my thrift store phase and wearing LOTS of velour from the 70s, I thought it sounded wonderful. I digress.

And speak of opera and no microphones: again, I don't know enough to really dissect anything she did, but Denise DiDonato popped on to do an aria of Rossini's and tore that shit up (that's a technical opera term). It was a pretty showy piece. And she showed it. She also gave a wonderfully charming introduction about why she picked it, what was different about opera and musical theater, and blah blah blah. Point is: she was super cute.

Tyne Daly was ridiculously wonderful doing a comedic song about embracing being fat. It was, I think, a Sophie Tucker number. And she slaughtered it. What else would you expect from Cagney. OR...was it Lacey. Oh, let's be honest: I just think of her as one of the titans of the stage who played Mama Rose. Along with Angela Lansbury! Where are Patti LuPone, Bernadette Peters, Linda Lavin, and the ghost of Ethel Merman when you need them? And why can I name all of Broadway's Mama Roses? Don't answer that. She also read a small piece from Master Class. Luhv. Huhr.

Holy shit, this is getting long. I'm cutting too many people out! I'm not talking about Raul Esparza, Edie Falco, Jason Danieley, Barbara Walsh, or even Emily fucking Skinner! Emily you've-adored-me-since-I-played-a-Siamese-twin-in-underrated-but-brilliant-musical-Side-Show Skinner! She was great! They were all great! But best in show goes to:

Marin Mazzie and Brian Stokes Mitchell. Ragtime's original Mother and Coalhouse performing incredible songs from the roles they created--"Back to Before" and "Wheels of a Dream." It felt bizarre to see recreations of performances that I had actually seen. It's only been 13 years. I was 17! Aren't I too young for this sort of theatrical nostalgia? Who the hell cares? They blew the songs away. If Audra McDonald had come out and sung "Your Daddy's Hands," I would have just died. Mazzie and Mitchell clearly were both reveling in the moment and went whole hog on the vocals going for power over subtlety. And you know that? It was the perfect night for it. They killed, gutted, and buried those songs. They were fabulous.

The whole thing was fabulous. It was a really lovely evening. Am I McNally's biggest fan? No. Was I more than happy and enthusiastic to take some small part in a night celebrating him? Absotutley. When he's on, he's amazing. And his Cliff's Notes version of his career made me want to learn more about the plays I don't know as well. That can only be a good sign.